The facts and figures have changed since then, but the problem of missing children continues to grow, feeding into the weaknesses of our child protection systems. The recent Nithari case has underlined some of the gruesome possibilities that are a consequence of ignoring the issue. All of these come into play not only in the matter of the Nithari serial killing of children, but in the larger field of child rights and the problem of missing children.
2004 - Round trip: Kolkatta via Delhi to Alwar and back in one year. This was the journey of a kidnapped girl who escaped her year long sexual abuse and arrived at a CHILDLINE office. She was repatriated and her abuser was arrested and sentenced to a seven year jail term.
2005 - Disabled and abandoned: No takers for this four year old blind, dumb and mentally challenged boy found by Melmaruvathur police. Chennai CHILDLINE knocked on the doors of the State Special Commission and the District Rehabilitation Office before managing to finally place the boy in a shelter through the Juvenile Home for boys.
2006 - Nithari: 38 missing children. 17 of these children are now known to have been killed. Pornography, abuse and psychopathic serial killers explode into the consciousness of all of us.
Missing Children (An Overview)
How many missing children are reported missing across the country each year? How many of those reported missing, are recovered and return to their parents and guardians? How many children actually go missing every year, versus the number reported? Where do they go?
These and related questions are very difficult to address as there is no national database or uniform tracking procedure existing in India today that deals with missing children across the country. A dipstick survey of studies on diverse child rights issues, such as child labor or trafficking, and news reports post the Nithari-case* yield some figures for missing children. The consensus seems to be that these existing figures are questionable and cannot be treated as accurate indicators of reality.
“On an average, over 40, 000 children in India are reported missing every year, of which approximately 11,000 remain untraced. Where do they go?” (Haq: Report on Child Rights, New Delhi 2005)
A compilation of some of the diverse statistics related to missing children is both overwhelming as well as dissatisfying. The figures quoted from various sources are primarily indicative of the fact that there are large gaps in available information giving us a fragmented picture.
“there are 9,000 children who have gone missing from the national capital in the last three years. Over 2,500 children have been reported missing in 2006 itself, according to figures available with the missing persons squad of Delhi Police”… “As of Nov 15 this year, 6,289 children were reported missing in the city but we have traced 3,741 children”… “Asked if they kept records of traced children, the authorities replied in the negative”
(http://www.indianmuslims.info/news/2006/november/27/india_news
/9_000_delhi_kids_missing_in_last_three_years.html)
“Pune police wake up to missing children” … “Of the 1,176 children who went missing in 2006, 212 boys and 241 girls are yet to return home”
“Uttar Pradesh recorded 3,641 missing kids in 2006” … “While 712 of these children were still untraced, cops had recovered the bodies of 83 kids, mostly believed to have been killed” …
“According to official records, Meerut recorded 848 missing children, followed by Kanpur (806), Lucknow (767), Varanasi (510), Bareilly (285), Gorakhpur (282), Allahabad (143). It is also reported that 16 children were missing from different railway stations in the state” … “Of the missing children, 2,751 were boys and 898 girls, mostly in the 10-18 years age group. While 488 belonged to 5-10 years, only 145 were under five years” (http://www.indianmuslims.info/news/2007/february/08/india_news/uttar_pradesh_recorded_3_641_missing_kids_in_2006.html
“According to a website on missing persons managed by Bengal police and the National Informatics Centre, around 3,700 people went missing in 2004 and 2005 put together. The number was over 5,600 last year”
It is difficult to interpret statistics effectively, without uniform parameters, or compiling All-India data. Currently, figures don't tally when State-wise statistics are added up against the All-India approximate. In fact, as per the NHRC report, going by reported statistics, the total number of missing children possibly adds up to more than 50,000 a year on an average. This is based on only those cases that are reported and recorded. The number of children reported missing from the states/Union Territories mentioned in Table 1, minus those states/Union Territories with nil reporting, comes to an aggregate of 2,66,847, making an average of 44,476 children missing every year. The the average number of children reported missing in one year in Maharashtra is 13,881, in Delhi, 6227, in Madhya Pradesh, 4,915, in Tamil Nadu, 4,618, in Karnataka, 3,660, in Andhra Pradesh, 2,007 and in Gujarat, 1,624.
Missing Children of India - Issues and Approaches
“As per the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), crime against children is enlisted under different heads like procurement of minor girls, kidnapping for abduction ranging from exporting to ransom and about 15,000 cases were reported in 2005 as against 14,423 in 2003.” … “According to the National Human Rights Commission's report on trafficking of women and children, in Delhi alone, an average of 6,227 children go missing every year” (Express News Service 'Missing children figures in Delhi rising each year' January 25, 2007)
The NCRB, under the TALASH Information System, maintains a national level database of 'Persons Arrested, Wanted, Kidnapped, Deserters, and Escapees, Un-identified persons, Un-identified dead bodies and Proclaimed offenders'. The TALASH database of NCRB, as on August 2003, had 2, 01,710 items including 1, 09,626 records of missing persons.
How many cases are unregistered or unreported is unknown?
How many missing children are still missing is also not known?
Without a focused attempt to create a database that includes parameters of age, sex, and other demographic and psychographic profiling, as well as case / crime details and follow up reports, the statistics cannot lend themselves to any dependable interpretation.
The socio-economic spectrum of missing children in India has great range and diversity. Children leave home or disappear and may therefore be categorized as missing, for any one or a
Combination of reasons which include:
- To earn a living
- To escape abuse
- To elope
- To escape perceived threat or stress such as may be caused by exams or domestic violence
Some are sold to labor contractors or sex traffickers
Some are kidnapped for ransom
Every one of these children is equal to the other in that each one of them needs protection, guaranteed by law, government services and civil society. When a child goes missing, the first priority is the child's level of safety and the first concern is the efficacy of recovery mechanisms in place to track and find the child.
However, some of the ground realities we are currently dealing with are:
Most parents and relatives of a missing child do not know where to go, what to do or when to decide that the child they can't find is missing and hasn't just run away to a relative's house in a nearby town or village. In the poorest parts of this country, the general perception is that people in 'authority' are difficult to approach regarding a missing child. Most often, the prevailing attitude reflects the thought that 'missing children' are not as high a priority as an obviously criminal case. Among the richest sections of this country, a missing child is either a potential crime related 'case' or a 'family matter'. The latter being especially true in the case of a girl child. The issue of Missing Children by itself seems to fall through cracks in legal structures for civil or criminal procedure. Popular perception and reported experience is that even the first step of making a complaint or filing a report is fraught with difficulty. Speed in track & trace efforts involving coordination between multiple agencies, is the most essential in recovering a missing child. Speed is mostly not a ground level reality in the functioning of any system currently approached to report a missing child. In the gray spaces between these harsh truths, some of the most vulnerable children fall into black holes and disappear completely. These are the disabled, the girl child, the orphans and children in conflict with the law. The last category of child has absolutely nobody they can turn to for help, since the law that could perhaps be moved to help them, is also the law that they are in conflict with.
The average number of children declared “missing” annually in the country was calculated at 44,476 The National Crime Record Bureau (NCRB), the nation's central crime research organization, tabulates only cases of kidnapped children which it puts at 3196 for the year 2005 figures show a gradual upswing in the number of missing children in several states, led by Maharashtra (yearly average: 13,881), followed by Delhi (6,227) and Madhya Pradesh (4,915) Figures for 2006 are being compiled while according to police records in the past 15 years, 2,896 children have been reported missing and not found from various cities and districts of Gujarat Maximum city Mumbai is also number one when it comes to missing children. In 2006 alone, Mumbai's missing minor registers recorded 948 children as untraced The Patna High Court, while hearing a PIL on kidnappings, sought figures from district judges. Statistics showed that over 1,800 kidnapping cases were lodged in 2006 and 1,697 in 2005 An estimated 3,497 children, a majority of them girls, went missing last year and only 1,585 were recovered”
On an average, 170 kids go missing in Rajasthan every year Over a thousand Kerala parents went through the ordeal last year As of December 31 last year, the number of untraced children in MP was 1913 Of the 15,000 who went missing from the Capital last year, 7,000 were minors From 2003 to 2006, of the 8,681 children who went missing, 8,014 were “traced” and 667 were recorded as 'untraced' Assam's Director-General of Police R N Mathur admits that missing children are “a big problem in the state” … From 2001 to 2005, for which complete figures are available, 3,673 children were reported missing”
It was finally on February 6, thanks to the court orders, that the government completed compilation of the figures of missing children for UP for the year 2006 and submitted to the court. As many as 3,649 children went missing in the State last year”
Figures for 2006 are being compiled while according to police records in the past 15 years, 2,896 children have been reported missing and not found from various cities and districts of Gujarat Maximum city Mumbai is also number one when it comes to missing children. In 2006 alone, Mumbai's missing minor registers recorded 948 children as untraced The Patna High Court, while hearing a PIL on kidnappings, sought figures from district judges. Statistics showed that over 1,800 kidnapping cases were lodged in 2006 and 1,697 in 2005 An estimated 3,497 children, a majority of them girls, went missing last year and only 1,585 were recovered”
On an average, 170 kids go missing in Rajasthan every year Over a thousand Kerala parents went through the ordeal last year As of December 31 last year, the number of untraced children in MP was 1913 Of the 15,000 who went missing from the Capital last year, 7,000 were minors From 2003 to 2006, of the 8,681 children who went missing, 8,014 were “traced” and 667 were recorded as 'untraced' Assam's Director-General of Police R N Mathur admits that missing children are “a big problem in the state” … From 2001 to 2005, for which complete figures are available, 3,673 children were reported missing”
It was finally on February 6, thanks to the court orders, that the government completed compilation of the figures of missing children for UP for the year 2006 and submitted to the court. As many as 3,649 children went missing in the State last year” (Full coverage on Missing Children http://www.indianexpress.com/)
The Indian situation on trafficking
In India the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) launched the Action Research on Trafficking in Women and Children, with the involvement of the Department of Women and Child Development, Government of India. UNIFEM, supported NHRC for this project. The study has brought out some important facts and figures around trafficking. The Ministry of Home Affairs estimates that 90 percent of India's sex trafficking is internal. India is also a destination for women and girls from Nepal and Bangladesh trafficked for the purpose of commercial sexual exploitation. In addition, boys from Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Bangladesh are trafficked through India to the Gulf states for involuntary servitude as child camel jockeys. Reportedly, Bangladeshi women are trafficked through India for sexual exploitation in Pakistan. The study has found a clear linkage between trafficking and those reported missing.
It has also brought to light that an average of 22,480 women and 44,476 children are reported missing in India every year. Out of which 5,452 women and 11,008 children continue to remain untraced.
Similarly the study found correlation between. Trafficking and migration. Law enforcement is hampered by serious limitations as trafficking is a very complex crime, extending beyond the jurisdictional boundaries of law enforcement officials.
This is further A Channel Four television documentary,
“Cutting Edge: The Child Sex Trade,” screened recently in Britain, showed how the authorities largely ignore the trafficking of children from eastern Europe. Romanian filmmaker Liviu Tipurita returned to Bucharest, where he met up with 15-year-old Laurentiu, who has lived on the streets for most of his life. Three years earlier, Tipurita had filmed the boy living in a cardboard box with only a sweatshirt to wear. Laurentiu and his friends have a precarious existence. Of the little money they earn, mainly from begging and selling sex, much is spent fuelling their addiction to sniffing glue. The documentary exposed how Western pedophiles were coming to Romania posing as tourists, and were then procuring boys for underage sex. “Tom,” from Britain, had originally come to Bucharest in the aftermath of the collapse of the Ceausescu regime to work in an orphanage. Using hidden cameras, Tom was shown discussing his Internet business—a web site offering to introduce men to Romanian boys. His clients came from throughout western Europe—Britain, Holland, Switzerland. He boasted that he had even supplied boys to a German judge. From Bucharest, Tipurita travelled to Milan. In one district of Italy's most prosperous city, the film showed how Romanian boys, some as young as 10, were being pimped for underage sex, often by their own fathers, brothers and cousins. Posing as a potential customer, and using a secret night-vision camera, Tipurita asked one young boy how much it would cost for one hour. He said he would have to ask his father. Thirty euros ($35), came the reply. Suddenly, a police car drove by, but they were only interested in looking for “illegal immigrants,” Tipurita commented.
The growing popularity of India as a tourist destination is bringing such tourism driven children commercial sexual trafficking to India's shores.
Missing Children are often in a number of high-risk situations and the links with trafficking are of great significance. Each year, some 1.2 million children are trafficked worldwide, according to the United Nations. The Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe estimates that 200,000 individuals are trafficked annually from Eastern Europe, a significant proportion being children. Some become unpaid domestic servants, or work in sweatshops, but many more—boys, girls, teenagers—are forced into prostitution and crime.
What is "trafficking in persons"?
"Trafficking in persons" shall mean the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons, by means of the threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability or of the giving or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having control over another person, for the purpose of exploitation. Exploitation shall include, at a minimum, the exploitation of the prostitution of others or other forms of sexual exploitation, forced labour or services, slavery or practices similar to slavery, servitude or the removal of organs;
(Source: UN Global Programme against Trafficking in Human Beings) “Of the estimated 600,000 to 800,000 people trafficked across international borders annually, 80 percent of victims are female, and up to 50 percent are minors. Hundreds of thousands of these women and children are used in prostitution each year”.
Some findings from the NHRC Report
54.8% police officers give no priority at all to trafficking, 25.3 give it low priority, 12.2% consider it to be a medium priority issue and only 7.7% think it is a high priority issue Reporting on trafficking appears to be only 40%. As stated by the police officers themselves, 60% of the cases go unreported The sex-disaggregated data of law enforcement shows that 93% of those arrested, mainly under Section 8 A (ITPA), 95% of those charge sheeted and 90% of those convicted were women 40% of the police officials were not aware of the issue of trafficking Only 6.6% of the police officials had undergone some sort of training/sensitization on the issue.
No comments:
Post a Comment